Two Open Letters to the Secretary-General of the United Nations and the Editor-in-Chief of The New York Times

University of Tehran President Warns UN Secretary-General and New York Times Editor-in-Chief Against Normalization of Attacks on Iran’s Critical Water and Energy Infrastructure

19 November 2026 | 11:38 Code: 56835 News Top News Selected News
visits: 25
Following the publication of an article in The New York Times dated November 16, 2026 (25 Aban 1405), entitled “War May Answer Longtime Riddle of Iranian Dams Built for No Clear Reason”, Prof. Mohammad Hosein Omid, President of the University of Tehran and Full Professor in the Department of Irrigation and Reclamation Engineering, specializing in hydraulic structures engineering, sent two separate letters—one to the Secretary-General of the United Nations and one to the Editor-in-Chief of The New York Times—warning of unproven hypotheses regarding the purposes of Iran’s water infrastructure and of the danger of eroding the civilian status of these facilities and justifying attacks on Iran’s critical water and energy infrastructure.

The New York Times article advanced the hypothesis that certain water infrastructure projects in Iran may have been constructed to support military and missile facilities [link of the news in New York Times]. 


In response to this claim, Prof. Omid emphasized the absence of direct and conclusive evidence establishing such a connection and underscored the necessity of examining the matter within the framework of Iran’s geographical, climatic, developmental, and legal realities.

Letter from the President of the University of Tehran to the Secretary-General of the United Nations
Emphasis on the Need to Consider Iran’s Geographical and Climatic Realities
In his letter to the Secretary-General of the United Nations, Prof. Omid noted that Iran is a predominantly arid and semi-arid country with an average annual precipitation of approximately 240 mm, less than one-third of the global average. Limited water resources, uneven precipitation distribution, recurrent droughts, and the consequences of climate change are among the country’s most significant geographical and environmental challenges. Under such conditions, the construction of dams and the development of water infrastructure for the storage and regulation of water resources, the supply of drinking water, the meeting of agricultural needs, and hydropower generation have been part of conventional measures in addressing the country’s developmental and climatic challenges.


The President of the University of Tehran, while emphasizing the necessity of independent and critical assessment of any project in terms of economic justification, environmental impacts, and long-term sustainability, stated unequivocally that criticism of the necessity or performance of an infrastructure project must under no circumstances be conflated with unproven claims regarding its military purposes.

Three Principal Concerns of the President of the University of Tehran in the Letter to the UN Secretary-General
This professor specializing in water articulated three professional concerns:


First, the protection of critical and civilian infrastructure under international humanitarian law. Citing Rules 54 and 42 of customary international humanitarian law and Articles 54 and 56 of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions, Prof. Omid emphasized the necessity of protecting facilities and infrastructure indispensable to the survival of the civilian population, including drinking water supply facilities and irrigation systems. He further noted that dams and dykes enjoy special legal protection owing to the potential consequences of the release of dangerous forces and the possibility of severe casualties among the civilian population.


Second, the risk of unproven hypotheses becoming a justification for military attack and the normalization of crimes against human rights. According to him, the dissemination and repetition of narratives that broadly link critical water and energy infrastructure to military activities will blur the distinction between civilian and military objectives in public perception. He stressed that mere geographical proximity or an unconfirmed analytical hypothesis does not, in itself, constitute a sufficient legal basis for targeting civilian infrastructure. He further stated that 95 percent of the water behind Iran’s dams is used for agricultural and municipal purposes, and that less than 5 percent may be used for industrial purposes; a fact that underscores the true and vital importance of these facilities in the lives and livelihoods of the people.


Third, the humanitarian and environmental consequences of attacks on water and energy infrastructure. He warned that damage to dams, water transmission and treatment networks, power facilities, and related infrastructure would have consequences far beyond the immediate location of the attack and would affect public health, food security, agricultural production, and the livelihoods of millions. In a country facing severe water resource constraints and recurrent droughts, such consequences would lead to long-term humanitarian and environmental crises.


In conclusion, the President of the University of Tehran urgently called upon the Secretary-General of the United Nations, in light of his responsibilities under the Charter of the United Nations, to devote particular attention to the protection of Iran’s critical water and energy infrastructure and to take appropriate measures in assessing the humanitarian consequences of potential attacks, in international monitoring, and in preventing further violations of international humanitarian law.


To receive Prof. Mohammad Hosein Omid’s letter to the Secretary-General of the United Nations, please click [here].


Seven Critical Axes in the Letter from the President of the University of Tehran to the Editor-in-Chief of The New York Times
In his second letter, addressed to the Editor-in-Chief of The New York Times, Prof. Omid addressed the professional responsibility of journalism and the media in publishing documented information and critiqued the analytical and methodological foundations of the article along seven axes.


First, he criticized the characterization of dam construction in Iran as a riddle justified on military grounds, without regard to Iran’s arid and semi-arid climatic conditions. He asked the editor, when publishing such material without any corroborating evidence, to pay attention to economic feasibility assessments, environmental consequences, and long-term sustainability. He stressed that dam construction in Iran is neither an unknown phenomenon nor one requiring a military explanation; rather, it must be examined within the context of the country’s climatic conditions, water resource constraints, and developmental needs.


Second, he stated that the co-location of dam construction sites with certain military installations does not establish causation. The mere presence of certain military facilities in the vicinity of dams and water infrastructure does not, in itself, prove a connection between the purposes of constructing this infrastructure and military activities. He called for corroborated and verifiable evidence to substantiate this hypothesis and emphasized the necessity of examining alternative explanations, including the construction of military facilities adjacent to existing developmental infrastructure.


Third, he criticized the speculative style of the report. The President of the University of Tehran noted that the use of terms such as “possible”, “speculative”, and “unproven” in the New York Times article does not necessarily absolve the media of responsibility for its potential impact on public opinion and on the interpretation of military operations; particularly since such narratives may lead to the blurring of the distinction between civilian infrastructure and military objectives.


Fourth, he declared a violation of the rules of international humanitarian law, in that the publication of such baseless and purely speculative material amounts to justifying military attacks on civilians and civilian areas. He asked the editor of the newspaper, given its international standing and influence, to clarify such important distinctions for its readers when publishing such claims.


Fifth, he criticized the use of the 2018 arrests of environmental activists without the presentation of independent evidence. Prof. Omid referred to the section of the article concerning the arrest of a number of environmental activists and the espionage charges brought against them, and explained that this matter—absent independent and verifiable evidence—cannot be used as support for substantiating the hypothesis linking water infrastructure to military objectives.


Sixth, he did not regard the silence of Iranian officials in this regard as evidence confirming the claims made, and asked the editor not to steer public opinion toward interpreting silence as implicit confirmation.


In conclusion, he reminded the journalism’s ethical and professional responsibility for the humanitarian consequences of publishing reports, especially in wartime, particularly since water and energy infrastructure are not merely engineering structures or technical facilities but vital necessities in daily life, public health, food security, and economic activity.

Request by the President of the University of Tehran to the Editor-in-Chief of The New York Times for Transparency and the Presentation of Documented Evidence
At the conclusion of his letter, the President of the University of Tehran asked the Editor-in-Chief of The New York Times to publish independent and verifiable evidence in support of the alleged connection between the construction of dams and water transfer projects in Iran and military objectives; to examine alternative explanations and the country’s developmental and climatic realities; and to clearly reflect the limitations and the unproven nature of the hypothesis in its subsequent coverage.


While emphasizing the right and responsibility of the media to investigate and publish information, Prof. Omid noted that reputable international media bear an ethical and professional responsibility for how information is presented; particularly when the matter concerns critical infrastructure and the lives of millions.


He stressed that when a media narrative, without sufficient evidence and through the selective presentation of information, the omission of alternative explanations, and disregard for legal and humanitarian considerations, contributes to the normalization or legitimization of attacks on critical civilian infrastructure, that media outlet cannot evade its professional responsibility for the potential consequences of such a narrative.


In conclusion, the President of the University of Tehran reminded that the protection of civilian lives and the infrastructure upon which their survival depends must be considered above military and political considerations and justifications; a fundamental principle of international humanitarian law to which the international community cannot remain indifferent.


To receive Prof. Mohammad Hosein Omid’s letter to the Editor-in-Chief of The New York Times, please click [here].
 

tags: Secretary-General of the United Nations The New York Times Critical Water Energy Infrastructure International humanitarian law journalism’s ethical and professional responsibility


Your Comment :